Sam’s Club Meat Guide to Ribeye, Brisket and Whole Cuts

Hands trimming fat from a whole boneless ribeye beside three thick raw ribeye steaks on a cutting board, with the headline Is a Whole Ribeye Worth It?

Sam’s Club meat prices put USDA Choice ribeye steaks at $16.87 a pound and a whole USDA Choice brisket at $4.98 a pound.

Prime runs $19.98 a pound for ribeye steaks and $5.98 for a whole brisket. All four are Member’s Mark Angus beef, listed at an average price and charged by actual weight.

Ribeye steaks went up $1.90 a pound since October while the whole roll held at $14.67, so the roll now costs $2.20 a pound less. By my math, it stays the better buy until trimming takes about 13% of it.

Sam’s Club beef prices

I checked Sam’s Club’s beef prices on SamsClub.com for a St. Louis club on November 21, 2026, and the listings note that prices may vary in club and online. Several moved since October 22, most of them down.

Beef cutPer pound
Whole brisket, Choice$4.98
Whole brisket, Prime$5.98
Ground beef, 88/12$5.98
Ground beef, 93/7 grass fed$6.32
Brisket flat, Choice$8.48
Top sirloin steaks$9.97
Whole strip loin, Choice$10.98
Bone-in short ribs$11.97
Flank steak$12.47
Whole ribeye, Choice$14.67
Ribeye steaks, Choice$16.87
Whole ribeye, Prime$17.97
Whole tenderloin, Choice$19.47
Ribeye steaks, Prime$19.98

Whole Choice brisket is the cheapest cut here, and a whole Choice tenderloin costs almost four times as much a pound.

Buying beef by weight has a few quirks.

  • The big number on each listing is an average price, with the per-pound price under it and the note “Final cost by weight.”
  • The listings offered pickup, plus delivery in as little as two hours, and a SNAP EBT eligible tag.
  • If you pay with EBT online, a by-weight item may carry a 10% weight debit, and the difference goes back to the card.

Ribeye, brisket and other cuts

Sam’s Club sells ribeye and brisket in sizes from 2.2-pound steak packs to cases of whole cuts.

Sam’s Club ribeye

Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus boneless ribeye steaks cost $16.87 a pound, and the average pack is $59.05, about 3.5 pounds.

The whole Choice ribeye in Cryovac costs $14.67 a pound, and its $243.52 average works out to about 16.6 pounds.

Sam's Club search result headed Whole ribeye runs $14.67 a pound: Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus whole beef ribeye, Cryovac, $243.52 average price at $14.67 a pound, final cost by weight
Sam’s Club

That’s a $2.20 gap, or $36.52 on an average roll.

Prime steaks are $19.98 a pound, about $43.96 for a 2.2-pound pack, and a whole Prime ribeye is $17.97, or $304.23 for about 16.9 pounds.

Bone-in Choice cowboy ribeyes are $16.47 a pound as steaks and $13.84 as a whole roll, the cheapest ribeye per pound I found, bone included.

A case of whole Choice rolls costs $14.47 a pound, though it showed out of stock at the St. Louis club. At the top end, two frozen 22.5-ounce Prime dry-aged cowboy ribeyes ship for $199.98, about $100 a steak.

Whole brisket or the flat

A whole Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus brisket costs $4.98 a pound, or $76.39 for about 15.3 pounds. Prime is $5.98, or $93.65 for about 15.7 pounds.

Sam's Club search result headed Whole brisket is $4.98 a pound: Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus boneless whole brisket, vacuum pack, $76.39 average price at $4.98 a pound, final cost by weight
Sam’s Club

A Choice brisket flat costs $8.48 a pound, or $58.77 for about 6.9 pounds. That’s 70% more per pound than a whole Choice brisket, the full cut barbecue cooks call a packer.

By the case, Choice whole briskets drop to $4.48 a pound, Prime to $5.48 and flats to $7.98, though both whole-brisket cases showed out of stock at the St. Louis club.

Texas members buy the most brisket by a wide margin, according to Sam’s Club’s July 2026 newsroom post on popular meats, which used 2025 data.

Sirloin, tenderloin and ground beef

Top sirloin is the budget steak at $9.97 a pound, under 60% of the price of Choice ribeye steaks. Flank costs $12.47, $4.40 under Choice ribeye.

A whole Choice strip loin, for cutting your own strip steaks, is $10.98 a pound, against $13.97 for Choice New York strip steaks. A whole Choice tenderloin is $19.47.

Leaner ground beef costs little more, with 93/7 grass fed just 34 cents a pound above 88/12. Sam’s Club’s July newsroom post named ground beef members’ top protein in 11 states.

One cut draws poor reviews. Daily Meal’s September list of meats not worth the price named the Member’s Mark grass-fed New York strip, an Australian import with no USDA grade, among the lowest-rated beef products.

USDA Prime versus Choice

USDA Prime is the scarcer grade. Prime made up 11.8% of fed cattle in 2025, and Prime and Choice together reached a record 84.4%, according to Certified Angus Beef’s Paul Dykstra in the Angus Beef Bulletin.

At Sam’s Club, the Prime premium is about a fifth of the price on every cut. Worked out from the listed prices, Prime adds $1 a pound (20%) to a whole brisket, $3.30 (22%) to a whole ribeye and $3.11 (18%) to ribeye steaks.

That still makes Prime brisket the cheapest grade upgrade in dollars, and the one I’d pay for first. On a 15.7-pound packer it comes to about $16 more for the whole brisket.

Returning meat to Sam’s Club

Sam’s Club will replace or refund a perishable item whose quality disappoints, under its perishable item return policy, and you don’t have to bring the meat back.

Sam's Club help page headed Refunds without returning the item: for perishable items bought in-club, members may request a replacement or refund at the club and are not required to return the item
Sam’s Club

For an online order, contact Sam’s Club with your membership and order number, or ask at a club, and throw the item away rather than return it.

Meat paid for with SNAP EBT can be refunded to the EBT card within 90 days of purchase, or exchanged for the same item, but never refunded as cash, credit or a gift card.

No-receipt returns, the 90-day electronics window and the other exceptions are in the Sam’s Club return policy guide.

Whole cuts after trimming

Whole cuts cost less a pound than steaks or a flat, but you pay for the fat too.

Bar chart of Sam's Club beef per pound: Choice whole brisket $4.98, Prime $5.98, Choice flat $8.48, Choice whole ribeye $14.67, steaks $16.87, Prime $17.97 and $19.98

Worked out from the listed prices, and assuming the steaks or flat need no trimming, this is how much trim erases each discount.

Whole cutSaves a poundTrim that erases it
Choice ribeye roll vs steaks$2.2013%
Prime ribeye roll vs steaks$2.0110%
Choice ribeye case vs steaks$2.4014%
Choice brisket vs flat$3.5041%

On the Choice roll, 13% is about 2.2 pounds. If the fat cap, lip and silver skin you remove come to 10% to 15% of the roll, my rough estimate rather than a measured figure, the meat you keep costs $16.30 to $17.26 a pound.

Against $16.87 steaks, that’s 57 cents a pound cheaper with a 10% trim and 39 cents dearer with a 15% trim. A careful trim keeps the savings, and a heavy one gives them back.

So a Choice roll now buys modest savings plus control over thickness. One TVWBB forum member carved about 20 steaks from a whole roll in February and froze 12, which would be about $12.18 a steak at Sam’s Club’s average roll price.

Steaks keep 3 to 5 days in the fridge and 4 to 12 months in the freezer, according to Nebraska Extension’s storage chart, which draws on USDA guidance. The freezer times are for quality, since food held at 0°F stays safe.

Brisket is where buying whole clearly wins. You’d have to trim away 41% of a Choice packer, about 6.3 pounds, before the $8.48 flat matched it per pound.

Cooking takes more. Smoked BBQ Source, a barbecue site, says brisket commonly shrinks 30% to 40% as it cooks. By my math, that puts a cooked pound of Choice packer at $7.11 to $8.30 and Prime at $8.54 to $9.97, before any trim loss.

The same site plans on one raw pound per guest. On that rule, a 15.3-pound Choice packer feeds about 15 people at $4.98 each, and Prime raises that by $1 a person.

Share this guideXFacebookPinterestEmail

Prices, fees and policies were checked when this guide was last updated and can change without notice. Sam’s Club Tips is an independent site and is not affiliated with Sam’s Club or Walmart Inc.

Related guides

  • Sam’s Club Turkey Prices for Thanksgiving 2026

    What the fresh Member’s Mark turkey, the hickory smoked turkey and the roasted breast cost per pound at Sam’s Club, what each size really rings up at, how much to buy per guest, USDA thaw-by dates and roasting times for Thanksgiving 2026, pickup before the Thanksgiving closure, and how Walmart, Aldi, Amazon and Costco compare.

  • Sam’s Club Wedding Cakes for 50 to 200 Guests

    What Sam’s Club’s two-tier and sheet cakes cost and serve, what to order for 50 to 200 guests, how that compares with the average wedding cake, when to order and pick up, and what Sam’s Club won’t make or deliver.

  • Sam’s Club Flowers for Weddings and Bulk Orders

    Sam’s Club bulk flower prices per stem, how the roses ship, the 48-hour claim and cancellation rules, the DIY bouquet bar, three flower budgets for a 100-guest wedding and the delivery days that trip up Monday and Thanksgiving weekend events.

  • Sam’s Club Rotisserie Chicken at $4.98, Pound for Pound

    What the $4.98 Member’s Mark rotisserie chicken weighs and costs per pound, what’s in its up to 18% solution, how online orders and SNAP work, how the chicken bites and other packs compare per pound, how Costco’s and Walmart’s birds stack up in Consumer Reports’ 2026 test, and how to store and reheat leftovers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *