Sam’s Club Pumpkin Pie 2026 Price, Calories and How Long It Keeps

A whole pumpkin pie in a foil tin with one slice on a white plate topped with whipped cream, cinnamon sticks and white pumpkins, with the headline Pumpkin Pie for a Crowd

Sam’s Club pumpkin pie costs $5.98 for the Member’s Mark 12-inch pie, which weighs 58 ounces and lists 12 servings. That’s about 50 cents a slice.

It’s made in the club bakery and sold for pickup or delivery, not shipping. The price can vary by club.

Clubs close on Thanksgiving Day, November 26, so Wednesday is the last day to buy one for the holiday.

Sam’s Club pumpkin pie price and size

SamsClub.com showed these numbers for a St. Louis club on November 21. The per-slice and per-ounce figures are my math from the listed price.

Member’s Mark pumpkin pieListing
Price$5.98
Size12 inches
Weight58 oz
Servings on the label12
Per sliceAbout 50 cents
Per ounce10.3 cents
Limit10 per order
Sam's Club pumpkin pie listing headed A whole pie for $5.98: the price panel shows $5.98, max 10 per order and max 10 per membership, and prices may vary in club and online
Sam’s Club

The Member’s Mark pumpkin pie listing says the pies are prepared fresh in club daily. It describes a flaky crust over a filling of pumpkin puree, brown sugar and cinnamon, and puts one pie at about 11 to 14 people.

It had a 4.6-star rating from 7,743 ratings on November 21. A banner above the name said more than 1,000 had been bought since the day before.

There’s a cap, too. The listing allows 10 pies per order and 10 per membership, which matters if you’re buying for a church supper or an office party.

It’s a seasonal pie. The listing calls it a holiday dessert, and The Daily Meal reported it back in Sam’s Club bakeries by early August. Sam’s Club doesn’t post a date for it to leave.

Pumpkin pie calories and ingredients

One slice, a twelfth of the pie, has 370 calories, according to the nutrition panel on the listing. The same serving has:

  • 15 grams of fat, 6 of them saturated
  • 420 milligrams of sodium
  • 54 grams of carbohydrates, including 34 grams of sugar
  • 7 grams of protein

Pumpkin is the first ingredient, followed by water, sugar and enriched wheat flour. The crust uses palm and soybean oil shortening, and the filling has eggs and nonfat milk.

The list also names three preservatives: citric acid, potassium sorbate and sodium propionate.

Sam's Club pumpkin pie specifications headed This pie lives in the fridge: keep refrigerated, resealable container, follow the use-by date on the label, net weight 58 oz
Sam’s Club

The Sam’s Club pumpkin pie contains wheat, milk and eggs. Its label says it’s made in a shared facility with pecans, walnuts, almonds, macadamia nuts, coconut and soy, which is worth knowing before it goes on a table with a nut allergy.

How long a pumpkin pie lasts

Sam’s Club says to keep the pie refrigerated and to follow the use-by date on its label.

For pumpkin pie in general, the University of Maine Cooperative Extension says egg-based pies belong in the fridge and keep up to four days. They also freeze, and they’re best eaten within two months.

The listing’s own tips go further on freezing. Wrap leftovers tightly in plastic wrap or foil, put them in a freezer-safe bag or container, and thaw them in the fridge for 10 to 12 hours. You can cut and wrap single slices before they go in.

The listing’s directions allow up to five days after thawing, one day more than the extension’s guidance. I’d go by the shorter window, and by the date on the label.

The pie is served chilled or at room temperature. The listing suggests a few seconds in the microwave for a warm slice.

Pecan, apple and other pie prices

Pumpkin is the cheapest pie in the Sam’s Club bakery by weight, at 10.3 cents an ounce. The pecan pie costs more than twice as much per ounce.

Bar chart of Sam's Club pie prices per ounce: pumpkin 10.3 cents, apple lattice 15.3, pecan 23.2, cherry lattice 24.9, chocolate silk 38.6
  • Member’s Mark 12-inch Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie, 72 oz, $10.98
  • Member’s Mark 12-inch Pecan Pie, 56 oz, $12.98
  • Member’s Mark 10-inch Cherry Lattice Pie, 40 oz, $9.96
  • Member’s Mark 10-inch Chocolate Silk Pie, 33 oz, $12.74
  • Member’s Mark 4-inch Assorted Mini Pies, six for $10.74

Two more pumpkin desserts were listed. A frozen Member’s Mark 9-inch New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake with 14 slices was $16.84, with $2 off through November 29, and a 32-ounce Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cake Roll was $8.97.

I’d skip the mini pies unless a buffet needs variety. Six of them cost $10.74, about $1.79 each, while two whole pumpkin pies cost $11.96 and serve 24. The rest of the bakery, from sheet cakes to cookies, is in the Sam’s Club bakery guide.

Sam’s Club vs Costco pumpkin pie

Costco’s Kirkland Signature pumpkin pie is $5.99 in its warehouses for the same 58 ounces and 12 inches, according to a Mashed comparison on October 27. That’s a penny more, and both work out to about 10.3 cents an ounce.

The taste tests split. Chowhound, on November 9, preferred the Sam’s Club pie’s firmer filling and stronger spice, though it liked Costco’s crust better. Tasting Table, on October 22, and FinanceBuzz, on November 15, picked Costco’s pie.

Supermarket pies cost about twice as much by weight. FinanceBuzz listed Walmart’s 10-inch, 37-ounce pie at $7.34 and Aldi’s 24-ounce pie at $5.29 online. By my math, that’s 19.8 cents and 22 cents an ounce.

The Sam’s Club pie has a ribbon to its name, too. The Daily Meal reported that a sticker on the container names it the best shelf-stable pie at the 2025 American Pie Council awards.

With a penny between them, the price shouldn’t decide it. Buy at whichever club you already belong to.

Buying pumpkin pie before Thanksgiving

You can pick a pie up in the club, or order it online for Curbside Pickup or same-day delivery. At the St. Louis club, the listing offered both as soon as 11 a.m. the same day.

It can’t be shipped, and it’s SNAP EBT eligible. The listing also carries the return or replace anytime promise from the Sam’s Club return policy.

Every Sam’s Club is closed on Thanksgiving Day, Thursday, November 26.

Sam's Club hours page headed Thanksgiving is a closed day: Holiday Hours and Closings lists New Year's Day, Easter and Thanksgiving as closed
Sam’s Club

Wednesday runs regular hours, according to Sam’s Club’s hours page. Plus members can shop from 8 a.m. and Club members from 9 a.m., until 8 p.m. The Sam’s Club Thanksgiving hours page has the rest of the week.

The listing doesn’t offer a preorder. With its banner counting more than 1,000 bought in a day, I’d buy on Monday or Tuesday and keep the pie in the fridge until Thursday.

The bird and the boxed holiday meal are covered in the Sam’s Club turkey guide.

Share this guideXFacebookPinterestEmail

Prices, fees and policies were checked when this guide was last updated and can change without notice. Sam’s Club Tips is an independent site and is not affiliated with Sam’s Club or Walmart Inc.

Related guides

  • Sam’s Club Turkey Prices for Thanksgiving 2026

    What the fresh Member’s Mark turkey, the hickory smoked turkey and the roasted breast cost per pound at Sam’s Club, what each size really rings up at, how much to buy per guest, USDA thaw-by dates and roasting times for Thanksgiving 2026, pickup before the Thanksgiving closure, and how Walmart, Aldi, Amazon and Costco compare.

  • Sam’s Club Wedding Cakes for 50 to 200 Guests

    What Sam’s Club’s two-tier and sheet cakes cost and serve, what to order for 50 to 200 guests, how that compares with the average wedding cake, when to order and pick up, and what Sam’s Club won’t make or deliver.

  • Sam’s Club Flowers for Weddings and Bulk Orders

    Sam’s Club bulk flower prices per stem, how the roses ship, the 48-hour claim and cancellation rules, the DIY bouquet bar, three flower budgets for a 100-guest wedding and the delivery days that trip up Monday and Thanksgiving weekend events.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *