Sam’s Club vs BJ’s Membership and Grocery Prices Compared

Two shopping carts in a warehouse store aisle, one with bananas, rice and bottled water and one with paper towels, eggs and apples, with the headline Same Fees, Different Perks

Sam’s Club wins the Sam’s Club vs BJ’s matchup for most shoppers. It tested cheaper on groceries in two recent price studies, and its $120 Plus tier now includes Walmart+.

BJ’s is the better fit for coupon clippers and late shoppers. It takes manufacturer coupons, which Sam’s Club doesn’t, stays open until 10 p.m. most nights and is the only one of the two in Massachusetts and Rhode Island.

Both clubs charge $60 a year for basic membership and $120 for the top tier, so the fee doesn’t settle it. What each club does with the extra $60 does.

Sam’s Club vs BJ’s compared

Sam’s Club and BJ’s differ in the perks, not the price, per Sam’s Club’s membership comparison and BJ’s membership page, both checked October 23, 2026.

FeatureSam’s ClubBJ’s
Basic membershipClub, $60 a yearClub, $60 a year
Top tierPlus, $120 a yearClub+, $120 a year
Top tier rewards2%, up to $750 a year2%, up to $500 a year
Top tier extraWalmart+ included5 cents off a gallon
Manufacturer couponsNot acceptedAccepted
Curbside pickupFree for all membersClub pays $3.99 on $50 or less
Delivery, top tierFree on $50+ orders2 free a year
Delivery, basic tier$12 an orderFrom $9.99
Closing time8 p.m. daily10 p.m., Sundays 9 p.m.
Clubs602 in 44 states267 in 22 states
Store brandsMember’s MarkWellsley Farms, Berkley Jensen
Store card at the clubUp to 5% with Plus3% One, 5% One+, no cap
App checkout limitScan & Go, $1,000 a dayExpressPay, $3,000 a day

BJ’s moved Club from $55 to $60 and Club+ from $110 to $120 on January 1, 2025, and Sam’s Club went from $50 and $110 on May 1, 2026, as the Sam’s Club membership cost breakdown details.

BJ's membership options headed Top tier, $120 a year: BJ's Club+ at $120 a year and BJ's Club at $60 a year, both with BJ's Easy Renewal
BJ’s

BJ’s Easy Renewal can charge from the first day of the month your membership expires, while Sam’s Club charges about a day before the year ends. Billing questions go to BJ’s Member Care at 800-BJS-CLUB or Sam’s Club at 888-746-7726.

What the extra $60 buys

The $60 step up buys more at Sam’s Club for anyone who’d use Walmart+, which Plus now includes. BJ’s Club+ answers with gas savings and free pickup.

Plus now includes Walmart+

Since October 20, 2026, Sam’s Club Plus has included Walmart+ Annual at no extra cost for the primary member, once the Sam’s Club and Walmart accounts are linked. Walmart+ costs $98 a year on its own.

Sam's Club membership comparison headed $120 tier adds delivery and streaming: All Walmart+ Benefits, including free delivery, gas savings and video streaming, checked for Plus at $120 a year and not included for Club at $60 a year
Sam’s Club

Plus also earns 2% in Sam’s Cash on qualifying club and Curbside Pickup purchases, up to $750 a year, and paying with the Sam’s Club Mastercard adds 3% more. Fuel, alcohol, milk and gift cards don’t count toward the 2%.

The case for and against Plus weighs its other perks, from free shipping to pharmacy savings.

Walmart+ in Sam’s Club Plus skips household and add-on cardholders, and Walmart.com purchases made with its benefits don’t earn Sam’s Cash.

What Club+ adds at BJ’s

BJ’s Club+ earns 2% back on most BJ’s purchases and takes an extra 5 cents off every gallon at BJ’s Gas. BJ’s annual report, filed in March 2026, caps the 2% at $500 a year.

BJ's membership comparison headed 2% back plus 5 cents off a gallon: BJ's Club+ earns 2% back in rewards and an additional 5 cents off a gallon at BJ's Gas every day, while BJ's Club gets neither
BJ’s

The rewards can be spent from $10, don’t expire while the membership is active and can be shared with the household member.

Both break even at $3,000

The 2% math is identical at both clubs, since 2% of $3,000 is the $60 upgrade. The caps differ, reached at $25,000 of qualifying spending at BJ’s and $37,500 at Sam’s Club, a gap worth up to $250 a year.

For a household spending $6,000 a year at the club and buying 600 gallons of gas there, here’s what each upgrade returns, worked out from the published rates.

Bar chart of what the $60 upgrade returns for a household spending $6,000 a year at the club and buying 600 gallons of gas: Sam's Club Plus $120 in Sam's Cash, Sam's Club Plus $218 counting Walmart+ at $98, and BJ's Club+ $150 from 2% back plus 5 cents a gallon, all above the $60 upgrade cost

Without Walmart+, BJ’s Club+ comes out $30 ahead, all of it from gas. Count Walmart+ at its $98 price and Sam’s Club Plus pulls $68 ahead.

Grocery prices in two studies

Sam’s Club beat BJ’s on grocery prices in both recent independent price checks, by a few percentage points.

AARP’s September 3, 2026 check of 28 grocery items in Monmouth County, New Jersey, put Sam’s Club first, BJ’s a close second and Costco third, using regular prices without sales or coupons.

In Checkbook’s Washington-area survey from November 2025, a 150-item basket cost 33% less at Sam’s Club than at Safeway and 28% less at BJ’s. That’s about $67 and $72 for every $100 at Safeway.

Checkbook’s Delaware Valley survey had the same order, 35% and 32% below Acme. By my math, BJ’s runs $3 to $5 higher per $100 of supermarket-priced groceries across Checkbook’s two surveys.

BJ’s does stock more name brands. Checkbook found the same brand at BJ’s for 71% of its basket items, against 58% at Sam’s Club.

The Sam’s Club and Costco comparison covers the third club in AARP’s study.

Manufacturer coupons at BJ’s and Sam’s Club

Coupons are BJ’s clearest win, since Sam’s Club turns them away entirely.

Sorry, we do not accept manufacturers’ or competitors’ coupons.

Sam’s Club help center

Sam’s Club does take vendor checks from brands such as Enfamil, Similac and Purina, per its coupon answer, and offers Instant Savings instead, markdowns that come off at checkout automatically.

BJ’s accepts all manufacturer coupons and puts its own coupons in the BJ’s app for every member. Tasting Table reported in August 2026 that one of each can go on the same item, but not two manufacturer coupons.

I think BJ’s coupon edge is smaller than its reputation. Matching Sam’s Club’s prices in the Checkbook surveys takes $3 to $5 in manufacturer coupons per $100 of groceries, or $156 to $260 a year at $100 a week, by my math.

Gas prices and fuel discounts

BJ’s Gas and Sam’s Club fuel stations price about the same, so the top tiers and the store cards decide gas.

In OPIS data reported by CNN in April 2026, both clubs averaged 26 cents a gallon below the national average. BJ’s own site says its members save 20 cents a gallon on average.

Each Sam’s Club sets its own pump price, the same for Club and Plus members, as the Sam’s Club gas prices rundown explains. The tier and card extras work like this.

  • BJ’s Club+ takes 5 cents off a gallon at BJ’s Gas.
  • BJ’s One and One+ cards take 10 or 15 cents off a gallon at BJ’s Gas.
  • Sam’s Club Plus includes Walmart+, which saves up to 10 cents a gallon at participating Walmart, Exxon, Mobil, Murphy and CITGO stations.
  • The Sam’s Club Mastercard pays 5% back on gas at any station, on the first $6,000 a year.

By my math, the Club+ discount covers the $60 upgrade on its own only at 1,200 gallons a year, about 23 gallons a week. At $3 a gallon, the Sam’s Club card’s 5% is worth 15 cents a gallon, the same as One+.

Pickup and delivery fees

Sam’s Club is cheaper for pickup and for frequent delivery on Plus, while BJ’s charges less for an occasional delivery at the basic tier.

Sam’s Club dropped its $50 pickup minimum for Club members in October 2025, though some recent comparisons still list it. BJ’s charges Club members $3.99 on pickup orders of $50 or less.

Sam’s Club Plus delivers free on eligible orders of $50 or more ($8 under that), and Club members pay $12 an order. BJ’s lists delivery from $9.99, with two free same-day deliveries a year on Club+ and a $100 Same-Day Select annual pass.

At two orders a month, that’s $0 a year on Sam’s Club Plus with $50 orders, $288 on Sam’s Club’s Club tier and at least $100 at BJ’s with the pass, by my math.

Sam’s Club delivery orders don’t earn the Plus 2% Sam’s Cash, which counts only club and Curbside Pickup purchases.

Hours and club locations

BJ’s stays open later, and Sam’s Club has more than twice as many clubs.

Since April 6, 2026, BJ’s clubs and gas stations have stayed open until 10 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 9 p.m. on Sundays. Most Sam’s Clubs run 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily, with Plus members let in at 8.

Sam’s Club had 602 U.S. clubs at the end of July 2026, in 44 states and Puerto Rico. BJ’s had 267 in 22 states in August 2026, and its annual report put 162 of its then 263 clubs in New York, Florida, Massachusetts, New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

Massachusetts and Rhode Island held 30 of those BJ’s clubs and have no Sam’s Club, according to ScrapeHero’s October 2026 store data. BJ’s has also pushed west, with four clubs around Dallas-Fort Worth by May 2026.

Where each club comes out ahead

Where both clubs are within reach, the numbers above sort most households.

Coupon clippers

BJ’s app coupons and manufacturer coupons work on Club as well as Club+, so a coupon-driven household doesn’t need the upgrade to use them.

If you already pay for Walmart+

Sam’s Club Plus at $120 costs $38 less than a $60 Club membership plus $98 for Walmart+, so the upgrade is ahead before it earns any Sam’s Cash.

Massachusetts and Rhode Island

Neither state has a Sam’s Club, so the choice there is BJ’s Club or Club+. With 600 gallons a year at BJ’s Gas, Club+ pays for itself at $1,500 of BJ’s spending, by my math.

Spending under $3,000 a year

Below $3,000 a year at the club, neither 2% reward covers the $60 upgrade. At that level the extra $60 has to earn its keep through Walmart+ at Sam’s Club or through gas, pickup and delivery savings at BJ’s.

Share this guideXFacebookPinterestEmail

Prices, fees and policies were checked when this guide was last updated and can change without notice. Sam’s Club Tips is an independent site and is not affiliated with Sam’s Club or Walmart Inc.

Related guides

  • Sam’s Club Car Buying Program, How TrueCar Pricing Works

    How the Sam’s Club Auto Buying Program works through TrueCar, who qualifies, what member pricing and incentives add, the Rollick e-gift cards for RVs, boats and golf carts, what Sam’s Garage really is and whether the member price beats negotiating.

  • Sam’s Club Travel Deals for Cruises, Hotels and Tickets

    How Sam’s Club’s cruise site works, when its Sam’s Cash posts, what six October cruise deals pay back as a share of the fare, the ticket, hotel and rental car site, who actually sells the trips, what Sam’s Club doesn’t sell and how Costco Travel compares.

  • Sam’s Club T-Mobile Deals and How the eGift Cards Pay Out

    What the T-Mobile station inside Sam’s Club offers members: the four rewards behind the $460 holiday offer for Plus, the $60 yearly eGift Card that covers the Plus upgrade, how many weeks each payout takes, Home Internet and business offers, this season’s phone deals, and the $20 Club membership T-Mobile customers sometimes get.

  • How to Cancel Sam’s Club Membership and Get Your Fee Back

    How to get this year’s Sam’s Club membership fee back at the Membership Desk, by chat or by phone, what the online Cancel Membership button really does, how a Plus to Club downgrade refund works, and what canceling means for Walmart+, Sam’s Cash, credit card Autobill and new-member offers.

  • Sam’s Cash Rules for Earning, Spending and Cashing Out

    Every way to earn Sam’s Cash, from the Plus 2% and the Mastercard to item offers, Bonus Offers and the new-member deals, plus when it posts, where it can be spent or cashed out, and how returns and lapsed memberships affect the balance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *